Fragile Responsibilization: Rights and Risks in the Bulgarian Response to Covid-19
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.22439/fs.i35.7086Keywords:
Biopolitics, Responsibilization, Control, Risk, Right to health, Covid-19, BulgariaAbstract
This article discusses the Bulgarian response to the Covid-19 pandemic. The Bulgarian case is characterized by an ineffective constitution of the individuals as subjects of responsibility for the health of the population, which resulted in a vaccine coverage considerably lower than the European average. The article argues that the fragile responsibilization is an effect of the response to the pandemic that, building on older post-socialist regulations of the access to healthcare, instead of restricting the circulation of bodies in general, tried to differentiate between economically productive and unproductive circulation and to limit only the latter by progressively increasing its differential costs (both in terms of time and efforts and in terms of risks). An analysis of the legal actions against quarantine violators, however, suggests that such a strategy stimulated the public to respond to the pandemic by calculating risks, and if the social actors nevertheless behaved irresponsibly, it was often because they took into account not only the risks posed by the virus but also smaller-scale risks affecting their social support networks. The authorities, however, tried to repair the unreliable responsibilization by articulating an ad hoc right to health defined at the level of the population. That biopolitical right to health was crucial to the implementation of certificate requirements. It was harmonized with individual rights by opening up fields of choice such as the choice between vaccination and daily testing. However, since the differential costs of the higher-risk options seemed irrational, the constellation of individual rights and right to health left a growing residue of irresponsible conducts justifying a further intensification of control.References
Actualno, “Evrokomisar predupredi, che Balgarija mozhe da se prevarne v iztochnik na nov variant na COVID-19,” [An EU Commissioner Warned that Bulgaria Can Become the Source of a New Covid-19 Variant], Actualno.com. https://www.actualno.com/healthy/evrokomisar-predupredi-che-bylgarija-moje-da-se-prevyrne-v-iztochnik-na-nov-variant-na-covid-19-news_1673533.html (accessed November 19, 2021).
Agamben, Giorgio, Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1998.
Agamben, Giorgio, State of Exception. Chicago and London: Chicago University Press, 2005.
Alpha Research, "Godina sled nachaloto na Covid pandemiata: Kak se promeni zhivotyt ni," [A year after the start of the Covid pandemic: How has our life changed], Alpharesearch.bg. https://alpharesearch.bg/post/976-godina-sled-nachaloto-na-kovid-pandemiata-kak-se-promeni-jivotut-ni.html (accessed February 28, 2021).
Armstrong, David, A New History of Identity: A Sociology of Medical Knowledge. London and New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2002.
Bakracheva, Margarita, Martin Zamfirov, Cecka Kolarova, and Elena Sofronieva, Zhivot vyv Vreme na Kriza (Covid-19) [Life at Times of Crisis (Covid-19)]. Sofia: self-published, 2020.
BHC. 2021. "BHC obzhalva zapovedta na Ministerstvoto na zdraveopazvaneto v chastta, zasjagashta zatvarjaneto na uchilishtata" [BHC files an appeal for the order of the Ministry of Health about the lockdown of schools] BHC. https://www.bghelsinki.org/bg/news/20211026-press-bhc-challenges-covid-19-school-closures (accessed October 26, 2021).
Blagoevgrad24, “VMRO: Vavezhdaneto na zelen sertifikat e socialen genocid! Kacarov da popade ostavka!” [The VMRO party: The implementation of green certificates is a social genocide! Kacarov shoud resign!] Blagoevgrad24.bg. https://www.blagoevgrad24.bg/novini/Bylgaria/VMRO-Vuvezhdaneto-na-zelen-sertifikat-e-socialen-genocid-Kacarov-da-popade-ostavka-1138343 (accessed October 20, 2021).
BNR, “Balgariya uskori vaksinatsiyata s 14% za 10 dni,” [Bulgaria has accelerated vaccination with 14% in 10 days.] Balgarsko Nacionalno Radio. https://bnr.bg/burgas/post/101509313 (accessed August 6, 2021).
Bragić, Dragan, Adrijana Šuljok, and Branko Ančić, “Determinants and reasons for coronavirus disease 2019 vaccine hesitancy in Croatia,” Croatian Medical Journal 63:1 (2022), 89-97.
BTV, “Delata sreshtu zyelyeniya sertifikat: Administrativniyat sad v Sofiya otkhvarli zhalbitye,” [The Lawsuits against the Green Certificate: The Sofia Administrative Court Dismisses the Claims], Btvnovinite.bg. https://btvnovinite.bg/bulgaria/delata-sreshtu-zelenija-sertifikat-administrativnijat-sad-v-sofija-othvarli-zhalbite.html (accessed November 1, 2021).
BTV, “Na praga na novi merki: Obsyzhda se zelen sertifikat za uchiteli, socialni rabotnici i medici,” [At the threshold of new measures: The authorities are discussing a green certificate for teachers, social workers and medics]. Btvnovinite.bg. https://btvnovinite.bg/bulgaria/na-praga-na-novi-merki-obsazhda-se-zelen-sertifikat-za-uchiteli-socialni-rabotnici-i-medici-obzor.html (accessed February 28, 2021).
Dąbrowska-Kłosińska, Patrycja, “The Protection of Human Rights in Pandemics - Reflections on the Past, Present, and Future,” German Law Journal 22 (2021), 1028–1038.
DeFacto, “Sas stanovishte na trima sadii Konstitutsionniyat sad prekrati deloto za zeleniya sertifikat,” [An opinion of three judges puts an end to the appeal against the green certificate to the Constitutional Court], DeFacto.bg. https://defakto.bg/2022/03/24/с-три-особени-мнения-конституционния/ (accessed March 24, 2022).
Deleuze, Gilles, “Postscript to the Societies of Control,” in Negotiations, 177-182. New York: Columbia University Press, 1995.
Deleuze, Gilles, Foucault. Minneapolis: Minnesota University Press, 1988.
Deleuze, Gilles, and Felix Guattari, Anti-Oedipus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia. Minneapolis: Minnesota University Press, 1983.
Dnes, “’Vazrazhdane’ gotvi zhalba do KS zaradi zelenija sertifikat v parlamenta,” [The Renaissance party is planning to appeal to the Constitutional Court because of the requirement of green certificates for entering the Parliament]. Dnes.bg. https://www.dnes.bg/politika/2022/01/07/vyzrajdane-gotvi-jalba-do-ks-zaradi-zeleniia-sertifikat-v-parlamenta.516300 (accessed January 7, 2022).
Dimitrov, Alexandar, “Ako zelenite sertifikati ne srabotjat, oshte po-strashni merki skovavat Balgaria,” [If green certificates do not work, even more fearsome measures are going to freeze life in Bulgaria], Blitz. https://blitz.bg/zdraveopazvane/ako-zelenite-sertifikati-ne-srabotyat-oshche-po-strashni-merki-skovavat-blgariya_news847975.html (accessed October 26, 2021).
Econ, “Spored edna treta ot rabotodatelite s"s zeleniJa sertifikat se narushavat choveshki prava,” [According to one third of the employers, the green certificate is an infringement on human rights], Econ.bg. https://econ.bg/Новини/Според-една-трета-от-работодателите-със-зеления-сертификат-се-нарушават-човешки-права_l.a_i.791463_at.1.html (accessed November 4, 2021).
EUrobarometer, “Public Opinion in the European Union,” Standard EUrobarometer 95 (2021). https://europa.eu/eurobarometer/surveys/detail/2532 (accessed September 30, 2021).
Ewald, François, “Insurance and Risk,” in The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality, ed. Graham Burchell, Colin Gordon, and Peter Miller, 197-210. Chicago: Chicago University Press, 1991.
Forman, Lisa, and Jillian Kohler, “Global health and human rights in the time of Covid-19: Response, restrictions, and legitimacy,” Journal of Human Rights 19:5 (2020), 547-556.
Foucault, Michel, Security, Territory, Population: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1977-1978. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007.
Foucault, Michel, “The Crisis of Medicine or the Crisis of Antimedicine?” Foucault Studies 1 (2004), 5-19.
Foucault, Michel, Abnormal: Lectures at Collège de France 1974-1975. London: Verso, 2003.
Foucault, Michel, Society Must Be Defended: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1975-76. New York: Picador, 1997.
Foucault, Michel, “Madness, the Absence of Work,” Critical Inquiry 21:2 (1995), 290-298.
Foucault, Michel, “The Risks of Security” [1985], in The Essential Works of Foucault, 1954-1984. Vol. 3. Power, ed. by Paul Rabinow, 365-381. New York: The New Press, 1997.
Foucault, Michel, “What is Enlightenment” [1984], in The Essential Works of Foucault, 1954-1984. Vol. 1. Ethics, Subjectivity and Truth, ed. by Paul Rabinow, 303-320. New York: The New Press, 1997.
Foucault, Michel, “Truth and Juridical Forms” [1973], in The Essential Works of Foucault, 1954-1984. Vol. 3. Power, ed. by Paul Rabinow (1997), 373, 65-67
Foucault, Michel, Introduction. The History of Sexuality 1. New York: Pantheon, 1978.
Foucault, Michel, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. New York: Vintage, 1977.
Foucault, Michel, The Birth of the Clinic: An Archeology of the Medical Perception. London: Tavistock, 1973.
Foucault, Michel, Archeology of Knowledge. London: Tavistock, 1972.
Gallup, “Lipsata na dostatachno dostoverna informatsiya za vaksinite sreshtu COVID-19, preboleduvane na virusa i nalichie na hronichni zabolyavaniya sa sred nay-chesto nazovavanite prichini za otkaz ot vaksinatsiya sreshtu COVID-19 kam momenta,” [The lack of sufficiently reliable information on Covid-19 vaccines, recovery from disease as well as chronic conditions are the most frequent motivations for refusing to vaccinate against Covid-19 at the moment], Gallup International. https://www.gallup-international.bg/45706/new-covid-vaccination-survey-reasons-for-refusing-vaccination/ (accessed March 24, 2022).
Gallup, “Veroyatni niva na razprostranenie na koronavirusa u nas i gotovnost za vaksinirane,” [Probable levels of Covid-19 transmission in the country and attitudes to vaccination]. Gallup International. https://www.gallup-international.bg/44426/possible-levels-of-coronavirus-dissemination-and-willingness-to-vaccinate/ (accessed February 18, 2021) .
Gallup, “Osnovni Izvodi i Hipotezi ot Nacionalno Prouchvane na Obshestvenoto Mnenie: Cennosti, Solidanost i Obshtestvenite Naglasi po Vreme na Koronakrizata,” [Basic Findings and Hypotheses of the National Survey: Values, Solidarity and Social Attitudes During the Coronacrisis], International.
Hohfeld, Wesley, “Some Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning,” Yale Law Journal 16 (1913), 552-556.
Kolodko, Grzegorz, From Shock to Therapy: The Political Economy of Postsocialist Transformation. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000.
Lorenzini, Daniele, “Biopolitics in the Time of Coronavirus,” Critical Inquiry 47 (2021), 540-545.
Lebert, Audrey, “Covid-19 pandemic and derogation to human rights,” Journal of Law and the Biosciences 7:1 (2020), 1–15.
Marinković, Dušan, and Sara Major, “Covid-19 and the Genealogies of Biopolitics: A Pandemic History of the Present,” Sociologija 62.4 (2020), 486-502.
Markova, Ekaterina, Obshtestvo pod Kliuch: Problemi na Sociologicheskoto Izsledvane v Systoianie na Kriza [The Lockdown Society: Problems of Sociological Research in Times of Crisis]. Sofia: Marin Drinov, 2021.
Manolescu, Loredana et al., “Early Covid-19 Vaccination of Romanian Medical and Social Personnel,” Vaccines 9 (2021), 1127.
Mauss, Marcel, The Gift: Forms and Functions of Exchange in Archaic Societies. London: Cohen and West, 1966.
Mediapool, “Predsedatelkata na KS: Zelenijat sertifikat ne ogranichava prava,” [The Chairwoman of the Constitutional Court: The Green Certificate does not Infringe on Human Rights], Mediapool. https://www.mediapool.bg/predsedatelkata-na-ks-zeleniyat-sertifikat-ne-ogranichava-prava-news330000.html (accessed December 12, 2021).
Meeker, James, “The political nightmare of the plague: The ironic resistance of anti-quarantine protesters,” in COVID-19, ed. Ryan J. Michael, 109-121. London: Routledge, 2020.
MVR, “Izsledvane v Hoda na Dejstvieto: Obshtestvenite Naglasi v Situacia na Kriza,” [Survey in the Course of Development: Social Attitudes in a Critical Situation],
Sofia: MVR, 2020, (accessed June 20, 2020) http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjgisPKiO38AhUdX_EDHZFUD404FBAWegQIAhAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fbcnl.org%2Fuploadfiles%2Fdocuments%2FAnaliz_MVR_2020(1).pdf&usg=AOvVaw2WIzetoBji6eHl2O9Mdroe
NCPR, “Obshtestveni Naglasi po Vyprosi, Svyrzani s Covid-19,” [Social Attitudes on Covid-19 Related Issues]. Sofia: NCPR, 2020. (accessed June 20, 2020). https://www.parliament.bg/pub/ncpi/20210104123952Обществени%20нагласи%20по%20въпроси,%20свързани%20с%20КОВИД-19.pdf
Nikolaeva-Glomb, Ljubomira, “Zaradi Bezotgovornost Mozhe da se Pojavi Bylgarski Variant na Koronavirusa,” [The Irresponsibility Can Cause the Emergence of a Bulgarian Variant of Covid-19], Bulgaria on Air. https://www.bgonair.bg/a/36-sutreshen-blok/239901-mozhe-da-se-poyavi-balgarski-variant-na-koronavirusa-zaradi-bezotgovornost-kam-obshtestvoto (accessed September 21, 2021).
Nikolov, Aleksander, “Rusia Prevyrna Krizata s Covid-19 v Oryzhie za Hibridno Maroderstvo i Psihologicheski Terorizym,” [Russia Has Weaponized the Covid-19 Crisis for Hybrid Marauding and Psychological Terrorism], Factor.bg. https://faktor.bg/bg/articles/rusiya-prevarna-krizata-s-kovid-19-v-orazhie-za-hibridno-maroderstvo-i-psihologicheski-terorizam (accessed May 10, 2021).
Popa, Adelina, et al., “Determinants of the Hesitancy toward COVID-19 Vaccination in Eastern European Countries and the Relationship with Health and Vaccine Literacy: A Literature Review,” Vaccines 10 (2022), 672.
Pūras, Dainius, Judith Bueno de Mesquita, Luisa Cabal, Allan Maleche, and Benjamin Meier, “The right to health must guide responses to Covid-19,” The Lancet 395:10241 (2020), 1-3. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)31255-1
Rabinow, Paul, and Nikolas Rose, “Biopower Today,” Biosocieties 1 (2006), 195-217.
Rahman, Muhammad, et al., “Mental Distress and Human Rights Violations During COVID-19: A Rapid Review of the Evidence Informing Rights, Mental Health Needs, and Public Policy Around Vulnerable Populations,” Frontiers in Psychiatry 11:603875 (2021).
Rose, Nikolas, The Politics of Life Itself: Biomedicine, Power and Security in the 21st Century. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2007.
Sapienza, Alessandro, and Rino Falcone, “The Role of Trust in COVID-19 Vaccine Acceptance: Considerations from a Systematic Review,” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 20:1 (2023), 665.
Showalter, Elaine, “Hystories Revisited: Hysterical Epidemics and Social Media,” in Performing Hysteria: Contemporary Images and Imagination of Hysteria, ed. by Joanna Braun, 27-40. Leuven: Leuven University Press, 2020.
Spadarro, Alessandra, “Covid-19: Testing the Limits of Human Rights,” European Journal of Risk Regulation 11 (2020), 317–325.
Stoykov, Dimityr et al., “Upravlenie na Pandemiata ot Covid-19: Podhodi, Merki, Rezultati,” [Governing the Covid-19 Pandemic: Approaches, Measures, Outcomes] Sofia: Gallup International, 2020. (accessed May 10, 2021). https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjlopDriu38AhUGS_EDHWFvB4IQFnoECAMQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.kas.de%2Fdocuments%2F286758%2F286807%2FGallup%2BBulgarisch.pdf%2Ff7fb6513-b7e6-e1c8-4509-0dbc9020a1db%3Fversion%3D1.0%26t%3D1592561631839&usg=AOvVaw0jZ5oJHh4Yz2Dkdh7Y0B-I
Trend, “Naglasi na balgarite spryamo koronavirusa i konspirativni teorii,” [Attitudes of the Bulgarians to Covid-19 and conspiracy theories], Trend. https://rctrend.bg/project/нагласи-на-българите-спрямо-конспира (accessed June 30, 2020).
Zahariev, Boyan and Ivajlo Yordanov, Naglasi kym Vaksinite i Vaksiniraneto sreshtu Covid-19 v Pet Romski Obshtnosti v Stranata [Attitudes towards Vaccines and Vaccination against Covid-19 in Five Roma Communities in the Country]. Sofia: Open Society Fund, 2021.
Zdrave, “Ombudsmanat poiska vednaga bezplatni antigenni testove i sertifikat za antitela,” [The Ombudsman Demands Immediately Free Test and T-Cell Certificates], Zdrave24.bg. https://www.24zdrave.bg/article/10309384 (accessed October 20, 2021).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Authors retain copyright to their work, but assign the right of the first publication to Foucault Studies. The work is subject to a CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 license, but despite these restrictions, authors can take for granted that Foucault Studies will permit articles published in Foucault Studies to be translated or reprinted in another format such as a book providing a full reference is made to Foucault Studies as the original place of publication.
